diff --git a/ghost/data-generator/lib/importers/MembersProductsImporter.js b/ghost/data-generator/lib/importers/MembersProductsImporter.js
index ff4a565225..631f563cf1 100644
--- a/ghost/data-generator/lib/importers/MembersProductsImporter.js
+++ b/ghost/data-generator/lib/importers/MembersProductsImporter.js
@@ -1,6 +1,7 @@
 const {faker} = require('@faker-js/faker');
 const TableImporter = require('./TableImporter');
 const {luck} = require('../utils/random');
+const dateToDatabaseString = require('../utils/database-date');
 
 class MembersProductsImporter extends TableImporter {
     static table = 'members_products';
@@ -32,7 +33,8 @@ class MembersProductsImporter extends TableImporter {
             id: faker.database.mongodbObjectId(),
             member_id: this.model.id,
             product_id: this.getProduct().id,
-            sort_order: 0
+            sort_order: 0,
+            expiry_at: this.model.status === 'paid' ? null : (luck(50) ? null : dateToDatabaseString(faker.date.future()))
         };
     }
 }