diff --git a/ghost/admin/app/components/gh-post-settings-menu.hbs b/ghost/admin/app/components/gh-post-settings-menu.hbs
index 749de1ccf8..f9424eb3e8 100644
--- a/ghost/admin/app/components/gh-post-settings-menu.hbs
+++ b/ghost/admin/app/components/gh-post-settings-menu.hbs
@@ -83,7 +83,7 @@
                         {{#if (eq this.post.visibility "tiers")}}
                             <GhFormGroup @errors={{this.post.errors}} @hasValidated={{this.post.hasValidated}} @property="tiers" @class="nt3">
                                 <GhPostSettingsMenu::VisibilitySegmentSelect
-                                    @segment={{this.post.visibilitySegment}}
+                                    @tiers={{this.post.tiers}}
                                     @onChange={{action "setVisibility"}}
                                     @renderInPlace={{true}}
                                     @hideOptionsWhenAllSelected={{true}}
diff --git a/ghost/admin/app/components/gh-post-settings-menu/visibility-segment-select.js b/ghost/admin/app/components/gh-post-settings-menu/visibility-segment-select.js
index 5904aac0b4..5c4fe10857 100644
--- a/ghost/admin/app/components/gh-post-settings-menu/visibility-segment-select.js
+++ b/ghost/admin/app/components/gh-post-settings-menu/visibility-segment-select.js
@@ -21,13 +21,6 @@ export default class VisibilitySegmentSelect extends Component {
     }
 
     get options() {
-        if (this.args.hideOptionsWhenAllSelected) {
-            const selectedSegments = this.selectedOptions.mapBy('segment');
-            if (selectedSegments.includes('status:free') && selectedSegments.includes('status:-free')) {
-                return this._options.filter(option => !option.groupName);
-            }
-        }
-
         return this._options;
     }
 
@@ -48,17 +41,20 @@ export default class VisibilitySegmentSelect extends Component {
     }
 
     get selectedOptions() {
-        const segments = (this.args.segment || '').split(',');
-        return this.flatOptions.filter(option => segments.includes(option.segment));
+        const tierList = this.args.tiers.map((product) => {
+            return this.products.find((p) => {
+                return p.id === product.id;
+            });
+        }).filter(d => !!d);
+        const tierIdList = tierList.map(d => d.id);
+        return this.flatOptions.filter(option => tierIdList.includes(option.id));
     }
 
     @action
     setSegment(options) {
-        const segment = options.mapBy('segment').join(',') || null;
-        let ids = segment?.split(',').map((d) => {
-            let slug = d.replace('product:', '');
+        let ids = options.mapBy('id').map((id) => {
             let product = this.products.find((p) => {
-                return p.slug === slug;
+                return p.id === id;
             });
             return {
                 id: product.id,
@@ -88,15 +84,15 @@ export default class VisibilitySegmentSelect extends Component {
                 products.forEach((product) => {
                     productsGroup.options.push({
                         name: product.name,
-                        segment: `product:${product.slug}`,
+                        id: product.id,
                         count: product.count?.members,
                         class: 'segment-product'
                     });
                 });
 
                 options.push(productsGroup);
-                if (this.args.selectDefaultProduct && !this.args.segment) {
-                    this.args.onChange?.(productsGroup.options[0].segment);
+                if (this.args.selectDefaultProduct && !this.args.tiers) {
+                    this.setSegment([productsGroup.options[0]]);
                 }
             }
         }
diff --git a/ghost/admin/app/components/settings/members-default-post-access.hbs b/ghost/admin/app/components/settings/members-default-post-access.hbs
index 071e11f089..7ee1fdfa5a 100644
--- a/ghost/admin/app/components/settings/members-default-post-access.hbs
+++ b/ghost/admin/app/components/settings/members-default-post-access.hbs
@@ -25,13 +25,11 @@
     </PowerSelect>
     {{#if this.hasVisibilityFilter}}
         <div class="mt2">
-            <GhMembersSegmentSelect
-                @hideLabels={{true}}
+            <GhPostSettingsMenu::VisibilitySegmentSelect
                 @selectDefaultProduct={{true}}
-                @segment={{this.settings.defaultContentVisibility}}
+                @tiers={{this.visibilityTiers}}
                 @onChange={{action "setVisibility"}}
                 @renderInPlace={{true}}
-                @hideDefaultSegments={{true}}
                 @hideOptionsWhenAllSelected={{true}}
             />
             {{#if this.showSegmentError}}
diff --git a/ghost/admin/app/components/settings/members-default-post-access.js b/ghost/admin/app/components/settings/members-default-post-access.js
index afd4dfb9d1..825686988f 100644
--- a/ghost/admin/app/components/settings/members-default-post-access.js
+++ b/ghost/admin/app/components/settings/members-default-post-access.js
@@ -32,7 +32,7 @@ export default class SettingsMembersDefaultPostAccess extends Component {
             defaultOptions.push({
                 name: 'Specific tier(s)',
                 description: 'Members with any of the selected tiers',
-                value: 'filter',
+                value: 'tiers',
                 icon: 'members-segment',
                 icon_color: 'yellow'
             });
@@ -44,20 +44,29 @@ export default class SettingsMembersDefaultPostAccess extends Component {
         return this.feature.get('multipleProducts') && !['public', 'members', 'paid'].includes(this.settings.get('defaultContentVisibility'));
     }
 
+    get visibilityTiers() {
+        const visibilityTiersData = this.settings.get('defaultContentVisibilityTiers');
+        return visibilityTiersData.map((id) => {
+            return {id};
+        });
+    }
+
     get selectedOption() {
         if (this.settings.get('membersSignupAccess') === 'none') {
             return this.options.find(o => o.value === 'public');
         }
-        if (!['public', 'members', 'paid'].includes(this.settings.get('defaultContentVisibility'))) {
-            return this.options.find(o => o.value === 'filter');
-        }
+
         return this.options.find(o => o.value === this.settings.get('defaultContentVisibility'));
     }
 
     @action
     setVisibility(segment) {
         if (segment) {
-            this.settings.set('defaultContentVisibility', segment);
+            const productIds = segment?.map((product) => {
+                return product.id;
+            });
+            this.settings.set('defaultContentVisibility', 'tiers');
+            this.settings.set('defaultContentVisibilityTiers', productIds);
             this.showSegmentError = false;
         } else {
             this.settings.set('defaultContentVisibility', '');
@@ -68,10 +77,9 @@ export default class SettingsMembersDefaultPostAccess extends Component {
     @action
     setDefaultContentVisibility(option) {
         if (this.settings.get('membersSignupAccess') !== 'none') {
-            if (option.value === 'filter') {
-                this.settings.set('defaultContentVisibility', '');
-            } else {
-                this.settings.set('defaultContentVisibility', option.value);
+            this.settings.set('defaultContentVisibility', option.value);
+            if (option.value === 'tiers') {
+                this.settings.set('defaultContentVisibilityTiers', []);
             }
         }
     }
diff --git a/ghost/admin/app/models/setting.js b/ghost/admin/app/models/setting.js
index 318dd64731..16b58c1069 100644
--- a/ghost/admin/app/models/setting.js
+++ b/ghost/admin/app/models/setting.js
@@ -55,6 +55,7 @@ export default Model.extend(ValidationEngine, {
      */
     membersSignupAccess: attr('string'),
     defaultContentVisibility: attr('string'),
+    defaultContentVisibilityTiers: attr('json-string'),
     membersFromAddress: attr('string'),
     membersSupportAddress: attr('string'),
     membersReplyAddress: attr('string'),