ref https://linear.app/tryghost/issue/KTLO-1/members-spam-signups
- Some customers are seeing many spammy signups ("hundreds a day") — our
hypothesis is that bots and/or email link checkers are able to signup by
simply following the link in the email without even loading the page in
a browser.
- Currently new members signup by clicking a magic link in an email,
which is a simple GET request. When the user (or a bot) clicks that link, Ghost
creates the member and signs them in for the first time.
- This change, behind an alpha flag, requires a new member to click the
link in the email, which takes them to a new frontend route `/confirm_signup/`, then submit a form on the page which sends a POST request to the
server. If JavaScript is enabled, the form will be submitted
automatically so the only change to the user is an extra flash/redirect
before being signed in and redirected to the homepage.
- This change is behind the alpha flag `membersSpamPrevention` so we can
test it out on a few customer's sites and see if it helps reduce the
spam signups. With the flag off, the signup flow remains the same as
before.
ref GRO-54
fixes GRO-63
fixes GRO-62
fixes GRO-69
When the config `hostSettings:managedEmail:enabled` is enabled, or the
new flag (`newEmailAddresses`) is enabled for self-hosters, we'll start
to check the from addresses of all outgoing emails more strictly.
- Current flow: nothing changes if the managedEmail config is not set or
the `newEmailAddresses` feature flag is not set
- When managedEmail is enabled: never allow to send an email from any
chosen email. We always use `mail.from` for all outgoing emails. Custom
addresses should be set as replyTo instead. Changing the newsletter
sender_email is not allowed anymore (and ignored if it is set).
- When managedEmail is enabled with a custom sending domain: if a from
address doesn't match the sending domain, we'll default to mail.from and
use the original as a replyTo if appropriate and only when no other
replyTo was set. A newsletter sender email addresss can only be set to
an email address on this domain.
- When `newEmailAddresses` is enabled: self hosters are free to set all
email addresses to whatever they want, without verification. In addition
to that, we stop making up our own email addresses and send from
`mail.from` by default instead of generating a `noreply`+ `@` +
`sitedomain.com` address
A more in depth example of all cases can be seen in
`ghost/core/test/integration/services/email-addresses.test.js`
Includes lots of new E2E tests for most new situations. Apart from that,
all email snapshots are changed because the from and replyTo addresses
are now included in snapshots (so we can see unexpected changes in the
future).
Dropped test coverage requirement, because tests were failing coverage
locally, but not in CI
Fixed settings test that set the site title to an array - bug tracked in
GRO-68
fixes GRO-34
fixes GRO-33
This is a revision of a previous commit, that broke the browser tests
because changes in the data generator (requiring bookshelf had side
effects).
This adds a new way to run all tests with enforced numeric ObjectIDs.
These numeric ids cause issues if they are used withing NQL filters. So
they surface tiny bugs in our codebase.
You can run tests using this option via:
NUMERIC_IDS=1 yarn test:e2e
Removed some defensive logic that could be explained by this discovered
issue.
fixes GRO-34
fixes GRO-33
This also adds a new way to run all tests with enforced numeric ObjectIDs.
These numeric ids cause issues if they are used withing NQL filters. So they
surface tiny bugs in our codebase.
You can run tests using this option via:
NUMERIC_IDS=1 yarn test:e2e
Also removed some defensive logic that could be explained by unquoted ids.
fixes https://github.com/TryGhost/Product/issues/3738https://www.notion.so/ghost/Member-Session-Invalidation-13254316f2244c34bcbc65c101eb5cc4
- Adds the transient_id column to the members table. This defaults to
email, to keep it backwards compatible (not logging out all existing
sessions)
- Instead of using the email in the cookies, we now use the transient_id
- Updating the transient_id means invalidating all sessions of a member
- Adds an endpoint to the admin api to log out a member from all devices
- Added the `all` body property to the DELETE session endpoint in the
members API. Setting it to true will sign a member out from all devices.
- Adds a UI button in Admin to sign a member out from all devices
- Portal 'sign out of all devices' will not be added for now
Related changes (added because these areas were affected by the code
changes):
- Adds a serializer to member events / activity feed endpoints - all
member fields were returned here, so the transient_id would also be
returned - which is not needed and bloats the API response size
(`transient_id` is not a secret because the cookies are signed)
- Removed `loadMemberSession` from public settings browse (not used
anymore + bad pattern)
Performance tests on site with 50.000 members (on Macbook M1 Pro):
- Migrate: 6s (adding column 4s, setting to email is 1s, dropping
nullable: 1s)
- Rollback: 2s
closes https://github.com/TryGhost/Product/issues/4046
- when editing the member's email in Admin, the email_disabled field was
not recalculated, making it inconsistent with the suppression list
- now, if the new email is part of the suppression list, we set
email_disabled to true. Otherwise set it to false
refs https://github.com/TryGhost/Arch/issues/87
- The Members Admin API and members.* webhooks were returning too many fields in the nested `newsletters` objects. There was no "allowlist" serializer for the newsletter object, which meant every time we add a new field to the database we would unintentionally return extra fields without a second thought.
- With this change only following fields will be returned with `members[x].newsletters[x]`:
'id',
'name',
'description',
'status'
refs https://github.com/TryGhost/Arch/issues/87
- Round 2 for the previous commit. Removes use of `anyArray` for all
- Using `anyArray` in snapshot test is an anti-pattern which leads to leaking output fields unintentionally when the API changes.
- Adding these fixes is fundamental work before changing the output of 'member.newsletters' property
refs https://github.com/TryGhost/Arch/issues/87
- Using `anyArray` in snapshot test is an anti-pattern which leads to leaking output fields unintentionally when the API changes.
- Adding these fixes is fundamental work before changing the output of 'member.newsletters' property
fixes https://github.com/TryGhost/Product/issues/3752
- Added some extra tests for edge cases
- Updated handling of multiple subscriptions so they are handled better
- Canceling a subscription when the member still has other subscriptions will now get handled correctly where the status and products of the member stay intact
fixes https://github.com/TryGhost/Product/issues/3728
- When importing members from Stripe with an existing offer, that didn't
exist in Ghost, the offer never got linked with the imported
subscription because of a missing return statement.
- Fixes importing offers with duplicate names
- Added E2E tests for creating members from a Stripe Customer ID
refs: https://github.com/TryGhost/Toolbox/issues/595
We're rolling out new rules around the node assert library, the first of which is enforcing the use of assert/strict. This means we don't need to use the strict version of methods, as the standard version will work that way by default.
This caught some gotchas in our existing usage of assert where the lack of strict mode had unexpected results:
- Url matching needs to be done on `url.href` see aa58b354a4
- Null and undefined are not the same thing, there were a few cases of this being confused
- Particularly questionable changes in [PostExporter tests](c1a468744b) tracked [here](https://github.com/TryGhost/Team/issues/3505).
- A typo see eaac9c293a
Moving forward, using assert strict should help us to catch unexpected behaviour, particularly around nulls and undefineds during implementation.
no issue
This commit removes the `memberAttribution` feature flag from the
codebase. Some CSS classes are not removed as removing them and updating
the associated CSS files have side effects sadly.
closesTryGhost/Team#2895
- this was caused by the subject line being passed through the i18n
translator, which was escaping the content
- passing in `interpolation: {escapeValue: false}` when retrieving the
value prevents the content from being escaped
- modified a test to ensure the subject line is not escaped
fixes https://github.com/TryGhost/Team/issues/2783
refs cb05fae5a3
The root cause of the issue was the fact we no longer checked for lack of `newsletters` property on member data before checking its `subscribed` property which is now deprecated. This caused a cascading effect where `subscribed:false` property on a member overrides the value for `newsletters` data. The check was accidentally removed in a previous bug fix.
So for members that were not subscribed to any newsletters, saving a newsletter subscription failed as they had their `subscribed` set to `false`, and it was resetting the newsletter subscription to empty always.
no issue
The Stripe Mocker mocks the Stripe API in memory, to make it much easier
to test subscription flows. Currently it is more a POC to see if it
works well. It probably needs a bit more work to support more scenarios.
- Added new tests for the subscription stats endpoint for 3D secure +
free trial flows using the new Stripe Mocker
- Updated members admin api tests to use Stripe Mocker (+ added new test
for deleting members with Stripe cancellation)
- Some tests called mockStripe at the beginning, but that method did
nothing apart from disabling network (which is the default now), then
they mocked Stripe inside the tests file... so I've removed those
because those conflict with the new mocker that is enabled when calling
mockStripe. We'll need to port those over later.
- this cleans up all imports or variables that aren't currently being used
- this really helps keep the tests clean by only allowing what is needed
- I've left `should` as an exemption for now because we need to clean up
how it is used
refs: https://github.com/TryGhost/Toolbox/issues/389
This removes many error logs when the end-to-end test suite is run with the log-level set to error. Many errors are intentional, so the resolution is typically to stub the error log function and assert that it would have been called.
no issue
There are a couple of issues with resetting the Ghost instance between
E2E test files:
These issues came to the surface because of new tests written in
https://github.com/TryGhost/Ghost/pull/16117
**1. configUtils.restore does not work correctly**
`config.reset()` is a callback based method. On top of that, it doesn't
really work reliably (https://github.com/indexzero/nconf/issues/93)
What kinda happens, is that you first call `config.reset` but
immediately after you correcty reset the config using the `config.set`
calls afterwards. But since `config.reset` is async, that reset will
happen after all those sets, and the end result is that it isn't reset
correctly.
This mainly caused issues in the new updated images tests, which were
updating the config `imageOptimization.contentImageSizes`, which is a
deeply nested config value. Maybe some references to objects are reused
in nconf that cause this issue?
Wrapping `config.reset()` in a promise does fix the issue.
**2. Adapters cache not reset between tests**
At the start of each test, we set `paths:contentPath` to a nice new
temporary directory. But if a previous test already requests a
localStorage adapter, that adapter would have been created and in the
constructor `paths:contentPath` would have been passed. That same
instance will be reused in the next test run. So it won't read the new
config again. To fix this, we need to reset the adapter instances
between E2E tests.
How was this visible? Test uploads were stored in the actual git
repository, and not in a temporary directory. When writing the new image
upload tests, this also resulted in unreliable test runs because some
image names were already taken (from previous test runs).
**3. Old 2E2 test Ghost server not stopped**
Sometimes we still need access to the frontend test server using
`getAgentsWithFrontend`. But that does start a new Ghost server which is
actually listening for HTTP traffic. This could result in a fatal error
in tests because the port is already in use. The issue is that old E2E
tests also start a HTTP server, but they don't stop the server. When you
used the old `startGhost` util, it would check if a server was already
running and stop it first. The new `getAgentsWithFrontend` now also has
the same functionality to fix that issue.
refs https://github.com/TryGhost/Team/issues/2400
- we've deemed it useful to start to return `Content-Version` for all
API requests, because it becomes useful to know which version of Ghost
a response has come from in logs
- this should also help us detect Admin<->Ghost API mismatches, which
was the cause of a bug recently (ref'd issue)
no issue
With the increased usage of DomainEvents, it gets harder to build
reliable tests without having to resort to timeouts. This utility method
allows us to wait for all events to be processed before continuing with
the test.
This change should speed up tests and make them more reliable.
It only adds extra code when running tests and shouldn't impact
production.
fixes https://github.com/TryGhost/Team/issues/2366
refs https://ghost.slack.com/archives/C02G9E68C/p1670232405014209
Probem described in issue.
In the old MEGA flow:
- The `email_verification_required` check is now repeated inside the job
In the new email service flow:
- The `email_verification_required` is now checked (didn't happen
before)
- When generating the email batch recipients, we only include members
that were created before the email was created. That way it is
impossible to avoid limit checks by inserting new members between
creating an email and sending an email.
- We don't need to repeat the check inside the job because of the above
changes
Improved handling of large imports:
- When checking `email_verification_required`, we now also check if the
import threshold is reached (a new method is introduced in
vertificationTrigger specifically for this usage). If it is, we start
the verification progress. This is required for long running imports
that only check the verification threshold at the very end.
- This change increases the concurrency of fastq to 3 (refs
https://ghost.slack.com/archives/C02G9E68C/p1670232405014209). So when
running a long import, it is now possible to send emails without having
to wait for the import. Above change makes sure it is not possible to
get around the verification limits.
Refactoring:
- Removed the need to use `updateVerificationTrigger` by making
thresholds getters instead of fixed variables.
- Improved awaiting of members import job in regression test
fixes https://github.com/TryGhost/Team/issues/2386
**Issue:**
- When trying to import a member that already exists, and has
'subscribed' set to 'true' in the CSV, the newsletters the member is
subscribed to are reset to the default newsletters.
- When ediging a member with the API and setting `subscribed` to true,
the same happens.
**Cause:**
A faulty check for the `status` property of a newsletter.
Fixed and added a new E2E test.
refs https://github.com/TryGhost/Toolbox/issues/476
- The email verification trigger and host settings related bugs have been a cause of bugs in past releases. The admin client verification source did not have any test coverage in the past.
- The members test suite size is getting out of hand. This test is quite verbose, because of the state it's trying to check.
- In the future we should consider splitting up Member API (and probably other) test suites into smaller pieces.
fixes https://github.com/TryGhost/Team/issues/2129
- This changes how the activity feed API parses the filter.
- We now parse the filter early to a MongoDB filter, and split it in two. One of the filters is applied to the pageActions, and the other one is used individually for every event type. We now allow to use grouping and OR's inside the filters because of this change. As long as we don't combine filters on 'type' with other filters inside grouped filters or OR, then it is allowed.
- We make use of mongoTransformer to manually inject a mongo filter without needing to parse it from a string value again (that would make it a lot harder because we would have to convert the splitted filter back to a string and we currently don't have methods for that).
- Added sorting by id for events with the same timestamp (required for reliable pagination)
- Added id to each event (required for pagination)
- Added more tests for filters
- Added test for pagination
- Removed unsued getSubscriptions and getVolume methods
Used new mongo utility methods introduced here: https://github.com/TryGhost/NQL/pull/49
refs https://github.com/TryGhost/Team/issues/2077
- Members and Posts test suites were using a broad tiers property matcher, which is an anti-pattern for snapshot tests. Without more specific snapshots it would be very hard to track down tier-related breaking changes!
- This change is groundwork for a refactor coming in tier usage at API's output serializers
fixes https://github.com/TryGhost/Team/issues/2091
fixes https://github.com/TryGhost/Team/issues/2089
- Added new fixtures to make testing easier for the activity feed
- Improved E2E test coverage of activity feed with separate test file
- Added data.post_id filter to enable filtering by events related to a
given post
- Fixed return types in JSDoc of test agents (TypeScript interprets
these as `typeof Agent` if we don't add `InstanceType<Agent>`)
- Added total pagination metadata to activity feed API (to allow a basic
type of pagination using filters)
refs https://github.com/TryGhost/Team/issues/2047
- We anticipate upcoming changes in the PUT /members/:id/subscriptions/:subscription_id endpoint , so covered it with a snapshot test to track the differences more precisely.
- Note, the test case contains a more explicit outgoing HTTP request mocking.
no issue
- All content-length snapshots should be using the same matcher for consistency - anyContentLength. It's more explicit about what the matcher is all about and might be useful to have content-length matchers in one place if it ever changes (the header value should be a damn digit after all, not a string!) (ref. https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc7230#section-3.3.2)
- renames `refSource`, `refMedium` and `refUrl` to `referrerSource`, `referrerMedium` and `referrerUrl` respectively for consistent naming across files and usages
fixes https://github.com/TryGhost/Team/issues/1859
**Problem:**
When for some reason a member has an active subscription (or legacy comped subscription) for product A, and a comped subscription for product B. You cannot remove comped subscription B.
**Fixed by:**
Updating the API to allow more flexible product changes on members.
- Allow the removal of (comped) products on a member, as long as that product doesn't have a related subscription
- (still) allow the addition of comped products to a member, as long as that member doesn't have other active subscriptions. This matches the existing behaviour, but now this is only checked for added products.
- Includes tests for these edge cases
refs https://github.com/TryGhost/Team/issues/1833
refs https://github.com/TryGhost/Team/issues/1834
We've added the attribution property to subscription and signup events when the
flag is enabled. The attributions resource is fetched by creating multiple relations
on the model, rather than polymorphic as we ran into issues with that as they can't
be nullable/optional.
The parse-member-event structure has been updated to make it easier to work with,
specifically `getObject` is only used when the event is clickable, and there is now a
join property which makes it easier to join the action and the object.
refs https://github.com/TryGhost/Team/issues/1833
refs https://github.com/TryGhost/Team/issues/1834
We've added the attribution property to subscription and signup events when the
flag is enabled. The attributions resource is fetched by creating multiple relations
on the model, rather than polymorphic as we ran into issues with that as they can't
be nullable/optional.
The parse-member-event structure has been updated to make it easier to work with,
specifically `getObject` is only used when the event is clickable, and there is now a
join property which makes it easier to join the action and the object.
