nixos/btrbk: fix ordering of subsections and refactor

nixos/modules/services/backup/btrbk.nix

@@ -1,72 +1,74 @@
 { config, pkgs, lib, ... }:
 let
   inherit (lib)
+    concatLists
+    concatMap
     concatMapStringsSep
     concatStringsSep
     filterAttrs
-    flatten
     isAttrs
-    isString
     literalExpression
     mapAttrs'
     mapAttrsToList
     mkIf
     mkOption
     optionalString
-    partition
-    typeOf
+    sort
     types
     ;
 
+  # The priority of an option or section.
+  # The configurations format are order-sensitive. Pairs are added as children of
+  # the last sections if possible, otherwise, they start a new section.
+  # We sort them in topological order:
+  # 1. Leaf pairs.
+  # 2. Sections that may contain (1).
+  # 3. Sections that may contain (1) or (2).
+  # 4. Etc.
+  prioOf = { name, value }:
+    if !isAttrs value then 0 # Leaf options.
+    else {
+      target = 1; # Contains: options.
+      subvolume = 2; # Contains: options, target.
+      volume = 3; # Contains: options, target, subvolume.
+    }.${name} or (throw "Unknow section '${name}'");
+
+  genConfig' = set: concatStringsSep "\n" (genConfig set);
+  genConfig = set:
+    let
+      pairs = mapAttrsToList (name: value: { inherit name value; }) set;
+      sortedPairs = sort (a: b: prioOf a < prioOf b) pairs;
+    in
+      concatMap genPair sortedPairs;
+  genSection = sec: secName: value:
+    [ "${sec} ${secName}" ] ++ map (x: " " + x) (genConfig value);
+  genPair = { name, value }:
+    if !isAttrs value
+    then [ "${name} ${value}" ]
+    else concatLists (mapAttrsToList (genSection name) value);
+
+  addDefaults = settings: { backend = "btrfs-progs-sudo"; } // settings;
+
+  mkConfigFile = name: settings: pkgs.writeTextFile {
+    name = "btrbk-${name}.conf";
+    text = genConfig' (addDefaults settings);
+    checkPhase = ''
+      set +e
+      ${pkgs.btrbk}/bin/btrbk -c $out dryrun
+      # According to btrbk(1), exit status 2 means parse error
+      # for CLI options or the config file.
+      if [[ $? == 2 ]]; then
+        echo "Btrbk configuration is invalid:"
+        cat $out
+        exit 1
+      fi
+      set -e
+    '';
+  };
+
   cfg = config.services.btrbk;
   sshEnabled = cfg.sshAccess != [ ];
   serviceEnabled = cfg.instances != { };
-  attr2Lines = attr:
-    let
-      pairs = mapAttrsToList (name: value: { inherit name value; }) attr;
-      isSubsection = value:
-        if isAttrs value then true
-        else if isString value then false
-        else throw "invalid type in btrbk config ${typeOf value}";
-      sortedPairs = partition (x: isSubsection x.value) pairs;
-    in
-    flatten (
-      # non subsections go first
-      (
-        map (pair: [ "${pair.name} ${pair.value}" ]) sortedPairs.wrong
-      )
-      ++ # subsections go last
-      (
-        map
-          (
-            pair:
-            mapAttrsToList
-              (
-                childname: value:
-                  [ "${pair.name} ${childname}" ] ++ (map (x: " " + x) (attr2Lines value))
-              )
-              pair.value
-          )
-          sortedPairs.right
-      )
-    )
-  ;
-  addDefaults = settings: { backend = "btrfs-progs-sudo"; } // settings;
-  mkConfigFile = settings: concatStringsSep "\n" (attr2Lines (addDefaults settings));
-  mkTestedConfigFile = name: settings:
-    let
-      configFile = pkgs.writeText "btrbk-${name}.conf" (mkConfigFile settings);
-    in
-    pkgs.runCommand "btrbk-${name}-tested.conf" { } ''
-      mkdir foo
-      cp ${configFile} $out
-      if (set +o pipefail; ${pkgs.btrbk}/bin/btrbk -c $out ls foo 2>&1 | grep $out);
-      then
-      echo btrbk configuration is invalid
-      cat $out
-      exit 1
-      fi;
-    '';
 in
 {
   meta.maintainers = with lib.maintainers; [ oxalica ];
@@ -196,7 +198,7 @@ in
       (
         name: instance: {
           name = "btrbk/${name}.conf";
-          value.source = mkTestedConfigFile name instance.settings;
+          value.source = mkConfigFile name instance.settings;
         }
       )
       cfg.instances;

nixos/tests/all-tests.nix

@@ -102,6 +102,7 @@ in {
   brscan5 = handleTest ./brscan5.nix {};
   btrbk = handleTest ./btrbk.nix {};
   btrbk-no-timer = handleTest ./btrbk-no-timer.nix {};
+  btrbk-section-order = handleTest ./btrbk-section-order.nix {};
   buildbot = handleTest ./buildbot.nix {};
   buildkite-agents = handleTest ./buildkite-agents.nix {};
   caddy = handleTest ./caddy.nix {};

nixos/tests/btrbk-section-order.nix

@@ -0,0 +1,51 @@
+# This tests validates the order of generated sections that may contain
+# other sections.
+# When a `volume` section has both `subvolume` and `target` children,
+# `target` must go before `subvolume`. Otherwise, `target` will become
+# a child of the last `subvolume` instead of `volume`, due to the
+# order-sensitive config format.
+#
+# Issue: https://github.com/NixOS/nixpkgs/issues/195660
+import ./make-test-python.nix ({ lib, pkgs, ... }: {
+  name = "btrbk-section-order";
+  meta.maintainers = with lib.maintainers; [ oxalica ];
+
+  nodes.machine = { ... }: {
+    services.btrbk.instances.local = {
+      onCalendar = null;
+      settings = {
+        timestamp_format = "long";
+        target."ssh://global-target/".ssh_user = "root";
+        volume."/btrfs" = {
+          snapshot_dir = "/volume-snapshots";
+          target."ssh://volume-target/".ssh_user = "root";
+          subvolume."@subvolume" = {
+            snapshot_dir = "/subvolume-snapshots";
+            target."ssh://subvolume-target/".ssh_user = "root";
+          };
+        };
+      };
+    };
+  };
+
+  testScript = ''
+    machine.wait_for_unit("basic.target")
+    got = machine.succeed("cat /etc/btrbk/local.conf")
+    expect = """
+    backend btrfs-progs-sudo
+    timestamp_format long
+    target ssh://global-target/
+     ssh_user root
+    volume /btrfs
+     snapshot_dir /volume-snapshots
+     target ssh://volume-target/
+      ssh_user root
+     subvolume @subvolume
+      snapshot_dir /subvolume-snapshots
+      target ssh://subvolume-target/
+       ssh_user root
+    """.strip()
+    print(got)
+    assert got == expect
+  '';
+})