urbit/CONTRIBUTING.md

# Contributing to Urbit

Thank you for your interest in contributing to Urbit.

See [urbit.org/using/install][start] for basic orientation and usage
instructions.  You may also want to subscribe to [urbit-dev][list], the Urbit
development mailing list. For specific information on contributing to the Urbit
interface, see its [contribution guidelines][interface].

For information on Arvo's maintainers, see [pkg/arvo][main].

For more extensive information on Urbit development, such as how to set up an
environment and how to submit a grant, see the [developer documentation][dev].

[start]: https://urbit.org/using/install
[interface]: /pkg/interface/CONTRIBUTING.md
[dev]: https://urbit.org/docs/development

## Fake ships

You may have an identity on the live network, but doing all your development on
the live network would be cumbersome and unnecessary.  Standard practice in
Urbit development is to work on a fake `~zod`.  Fake ships use deterministic
keys (derived from the ship address) and don't talk to the live network. They
can talk to each other over the local loopback.

To start a fake ship, simply specify the name with `-F`:

```
$ urbit -F zod
```

You can also pass a name for the *pier* (or ship directory):

```
$ urbit -F zod -c my-fake-zod
```

To resume a fake ship, just pass the name of the pier:

```
$ urbit my-fake-zod
```

Fake ships by default use the same pre-compiled kernelspace ('pills') as livenet
ships do: boot pills, which are not always current with `master`. If you wish to
develop using code off the master branch, run the following from the repo
directory:

```
git lfs install
git lfs pull
urbit -F zod -B "bin/solid.pill" -A "pkg/arvo"
```

## Git practice

### Contributing

The canonical source tree is the `master` branch of
[https://github.com/urbit/urbit][repo].  You should typically branch off of
`master` when commencing new work. Most pull requests should be merging into
one of the `next/*` branches, depending on what part of the system the pull
request is targeting.

Since we use GitHub, we request you contribute via a GitHub pull request. Tag
the [maintainer][main] for the component. If you have a question for the
maintainer, you can direct message them from your Urbit ship using that
information.

When contributing changes, via whatever means, make sure you describe them
appropriately.  You should attach a reasonably high-level summary of what the
changes are and what they do; reference any useful background material that may
exist, e.g. a GitHub issue, a mailing list discussion, a UP, etc.  [Here][jbpr]
is a good example of a pull request with a useful, concise description.

If your changes replace significant extant functionality, be sure to compare
them with the thing you're replacing.  You may also want to cc reviewers,
or other parties who might have a particular interest in what you're
contributing.

[jbpr]: https://github.com/urbit/urbit/pull/1782

### Hygiene

Commits should generally be relevant, atomic, and have descriptions formatted
in the following manner:

>  component: short description
>
>  long description

The 'component' is a short prefix of what area of the codebase the commit
applies to.  If a commit patches `%gall`, for example, the description should
be prefixed by 'gall'.  If it touches `:aqua`, it should be prefixed by 'aqua'.
If it touches multiple components, then separate these by commas, e.g. "gall,
aqua, ph" -- but note that this may be a warning that too many changes are
being packed into a single commit.  The 'component' and 'short description'
combined should be no more than 50 characters.

A lengthier description is encouraged, where useful, but is not always strictly
required.  You should use the longer description to give any useful background
on or motivation for the commit, provide a summary of what it does, link to
relevant issues, proposals, or other commits, and so on.

Here is an example of our commit format, taken from a commit in the history:

>  zuse: remove superfluous 'scup' and 'culm' types.
>
>  %zuse includes definitions for 'scup' and 'culm', both of which are
>  superfluous.  'scup' is simply (pair ship desk) and is used only in
>  the definition of 'culm', a tagged union in which three of the four
>  branches are commented out (i.e. are unused).
>
>  This commit deletes 'scup' and 'culm' and refactors what little code
>  made use of them.

Note that the short description is prefixed by `zuse:`, which is what the
commit touches.  Otherwise it just includes a summary of the change.

Here's another example:

>  build: give arvo a high priority
>
>  0bdced981e4 introduced the 'arvo-ropsten' derivation.  Attempting to
>  install both 'arvo' and 'arvo-ropsten' via nix-env will result in a
>  priority error; this assigns a higher priority to 'arvo' to resolve the
>  conflict.
>
>  Fixes #1912.

Note that it cites a previous relevant commit, `0bdced981e4`, in its summary,
and also points at the issue that it resolves.

If you're in doubt about how to format your commit descriptions, take a look at
the recent history and try to mimic the style that you can see others broadly
follow there.

When we say commits should be "atomic", we mean with respect to some distinct
logical unit, e.g. a type definition used across many files, or a single file,
or just a single function in a single file.  Commits should be atomic at the
level of *code*, not of entire features.  You don't have to squash your commits
into a single one that captures everything you're trying to do -- the history
will never make for pleasant bedtime reading, so focus instead on making your
commits useful for tools like `git-blame` and `git-bisect`.

Your contribution must apply cleanly to `master` in order to be considered
mergeable.  You may want to regularly [rebase your changes][reba] onto `master`
in order to both clean up any intermediate "development" commits you make and
to ensure that you're up to date.

If you're making a GitHub pull request, it's good practice to make it from a
topic branch, rather than `master`, on your fork.

### Pills

Any contribution that touches the kernel (i.e., anything in `pkg/arvo/sys`),
should be accompanied by an updated [solid pill](#the-kernel-and-pills).  Pills
are tracked in the repository via [git LFS][git-lfs].

Whenever you make a contribution to the kernel, please create a new solid pill
via:

```
sh/update-solid-pill
```

and include it along with your contribution.

Historically, we've sometimes included these updated pills in separate,
standalone commits (you will see plenty of "pills: update solid" and similar
commits if you look through the history), but this practice is considered to be
deprecated -- you should usually just include the updated pill in the same
commit that updates the source.

## Releases

We typically create releases by tagging appropriate commits on `master`, so any
given commit in `master` may not actually be present in the latest release.

We perform updates by pushing releases over-the-air to `~zod` approximately
once per week, so any contribution that can be deployed OTA will usually find
its way onto the network pretty rapidly.

If you want to propose a hotfix (i.e. a small, OTA-updateable change, usually a
bugfix, to some currently-deployed release) then simply make it clear that your
contribution -- whether it be a pull request, patch, or whatever -- is intended
to be a hotfix.  A maintainer can then deploy it to the network outside of the
normal release schedule.

Less frequently we release new Vere versions, which requires users to download
new binaries, and occasionally, while Urbit is still in early development, we
breach network continuity in order to release large changes that are difficult
to push out over-the-air.  Contributions to Vere, or non-OTA-able updates to
Arvo, will find their way into releases before terribly long.

## Code style

The Urbit project uses two-space indentation and avoids tab characters.
In C code, it should not be too difficult to mimic the style of the code
around you, which is just fairly standard K&R with braces on every
compound statement. One thing to watch out for is top-level sections in
source files that are denoted by comments and are actually indented one
level.

Hoon will be a less familiar language to many contributors.  We've published
some [style guidelines for Hoon][hoon], but above all you should try to mimic
the style of the code around you.  With regards to the style used throughout
the codebase: the more recently the code was written, the more standard and
accepted its style is likely to be.

## Kernel development

Working on either C or non-kernel Hoon should not bring any surprises, but the
Hoon kernel (anything under [`pkg/arvo/sys/`][sys]) is bootstrapped from a
so-called *pill*, and must be recompiled if any changes are made. This should
happen automatically when you make changes, but if it doesn't, the command to
manually recompile and install the new kernel is `|reset` in `dojo`.  This
rebuilds from the `sys` directory in the `home` desk in `%clay`.

Currently, `|reset` does not reload apps like `dojo` itself, which will still
reference the old kernel. To force them to reload, make a trivial edit to their
main source file (under the `app` directory) in `%clay`.

[arvo]: https://github.com/urbit/urbit/tree/master/pkg/arvo
[sys]: https://github.com/urbit/urbit/tree/master/pkg/arvo/sys

## The kernel and pills

Urbit bootstraps itself using a binary blob called a pill (you can see it being
fetched from `bootstrap.urbit.org` on boot).  This is the compiled version of
the kernel (which you can find in the `sys` directory of [Arvo][arvo]), along
with a complete copy of the Arvo source.

The procedure for creating a pill is often called "soliding." It is somewhat
similar to `|reset`, but instead of replacing your running kernel, it writes
the compiled kernel to a file. The command to solid is:

```
> .urbit/pill +solid
```

When the compilation finishes, your pill will be found in the
`[pier]/.urb/put/` directory as `urbit.pill`.

You can boot a new ship from your local pill with `-B`:

```
$ urbit -F zod -B path/to/urbit.pill my-fake-zod
```

Release pills, i.e. those corresponding to vere releases, are cached at
`https://bootstrap.urbit.org` and are indexed by the vere version number, e.g.
`urbit-0.8.2.pill`.

Pills are also cached in version control via [git LFS][git-lfs].  You can find
the latest solid pill, as well as the latest so-called *brass* and *ivory*
pills, in the `bin/` directory at the repository root.  Note that you'll need
to initialise git LFS in order to check these pills out:

```
$ git lfs init
$ git lfs pull
```

[git-lfs]: https://git-lfs.github.com

## Issues

The [GitHub tracker][issu] is our canonical source of truth around issues,
bugs, performance problems, feature requests, and so on.  If you encounter any
issues when developing on Urbit, feel free to submit a report about it here.

A good bug report, description of a crash, etc., should ideally be
*reproducible*, with clear steps as to how another developer can replicate and
examine your problem.  That said, this isn't always possible -- some bugs
depend on having created a complicated or unusual state, or can otherwise
simply be difficult to trigger again (say, you encountered it in the last
continuity era).

Your issue should thus at a minimum be *informative*.  The best advice here is
probably "don't write bad issues," where "bad" is a matter of judgment and
taste.  Issues that the maintainers don't judge to be sufficiently useful or
informative may be closed.

Feature requests are welcome, but they should include sufficient detail and
explanation, as well as a discussion of perceived benefits one could expect
from them.  "It would be cool if.." probably does not, in itself, constitute a
good feature request; instead, try to be specific about what you're requesting,
and what your desired feature would accomplish.

## Staying in touch

Questions or other communications about contributing to Urbit can go to
[support@urbit.org][mail].

[mail]: mailto:support@urbit.org
[list]: https://groups.google.com/a/urbit.org/forum/#!forum/dev
[repo]: https://github.com/urbit/urbit
[reba]: https://git-rebase.io/
[issu]: https://github.com/urbit/urbit/issues
[hoon]: https://urbit.org/docs/hoon/reference/style
[main]: https://github.com/urbit/urbit/tree/master/pkg/arvo#maintainers